Final Fantasy Republic Forums  
 Home | Forums | Register | FAQ | Members List | Calendar | Search | Today's Posts | Mark Forums Read
     
    
        
     
 
Final Fantasy Republic Forums  
Username:

Password:
CAPTCHA:
  
        
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  The Doctor
 
 
The Doctor's Avatar
Urban Spaceman
 
Posts: 507
 
Reg: May 05 2006
 
ID: 7331
 
RP: 150
 
Streets of Rage 2, Hitman, Halo, GTA, FFIX
Keane, Metallica
Sin City, Pulp Fiction, Fear And Loathing, Star Wars
The Da Vinci Code
PSP, PS2
     
 
Default  Violence in games
05.18.06, 18:35:31
  Post #1 (permalink)
 
     

i play a lot of games, including the more violent ones i.e. GTA. but they have never made me want to pick up an gun and kill. can such tragedies as the columbine killings really be blamed on doom and similar games? obviously NO! over in the UK we have the same games as the USA, no bits edited or dumbed down, and we never get high school shootings. I think you have to have a major screw loose in the brainbox to actually be effected by these games.

I've never thought that games were real, even as a 9 year old i played streets of rage and street fighter, this never made me want to grab an iron bar and start beating things up whilst looking for turkeys and puddings!

blaming games for real life violence is an excuse for bad parenting and silly gun laws....*looks at the USA gun laws* if teenagers can get there hands on guns, what do you thinks gonna happen!
______________________________________



FFOF
Send a message via AIM to The Doctor Send a message via MSN to The Doctor Send a message via Yahoo to The Doctor   The Doctor is offline
View The Doctors Profile! Find more posts by The Doctor! Visit The Doctors Homepage!   Reply With Quote
  Parks
 
Naturally.
 
Posts: 227
 
Reg: May 19 2006
 
ID: 7364
 
RP: 150
     
 
Default  05.18.06, 19:26:54
  Post #2 (permalink)
 
     

Parents don't take care of their children and this is why people blame games. Scapegoating to escape the idea of accepting responsibility as a parent. I believe it's all up to the parents to know if your child is mature enough to handle violence. Gun laws are a different story. They are mainly in place to prevent crime. Police where you live are probably prone to using much less violence because people actually fear the police and think about their actions (even while under the influence) after police arrive to assess a situation. Here Americans do not care. Money can buy you an attorney and if he's well trained enough you can
a. buy your way out of the situation
b. reduce the sentence to something ridiculously meager.
Send a message via AIM to Parks Send a message via MSN to Parks   Parks is offline
View Parkss Profile! Find more posts by Parks!   Reply With Quote
  Michael
 
 
Michael's Avatar
Community Manager
 
Posts: 2,160
 
Reg: Apr 21 2006
 
ID: 11689
 
RP: 0
 
ICO, Shadow of the Colossus, Final Fantasy XII
The Cruxshadows, VNV Nation, Sisters of Mercy
"From the Corner of His Eye" by Dean Koontz
     
 
Default  05.18.06, 20:14:02
  Post #3 (permalink)
 
     

Whilst I don't personally believe that games cause people to be inherently violent by nature, there's no deny if a kid is playing something like GTA constantly from the age of six or so, that's it's going to have some adverse effect on their behaviour.

Of course, that doesn't just apply to game. The child would have to be exposed to other forums of violent media regularly (such as music and telivision) to become so comfortable and accepting of such violence.

At the end of the day though, it just boils down to bad parenting. A parent who teaches their child that violence of such nature is acceptable and morally right, is going to end up with a violent child.

If the parent at least tries to make the child understand the inherent wrongness of such violence though, I believe they'll grow up to accept it as such, whilst still being able to play such games without it having an adverse emotional effect on them.
______________________________________



- THE VAULT WILL BE OPENED SOON -

I'm currently looking for gamers with an interest in the gaming culture and industry outside of Final Fantasy to help with a new, upcoming video game news site. If you think you're interested, please throw a PM my way.
  Michael is offline
View Michaels Profile! Find more posts by Michael! Visit Michaels Homepage!   Reply With Quote
  The Man
 
 
The Man's Avatar
The Abyss Gazes
 
Posts: 8,830
 
Reg: Feb 20 2004
 
ID: 6624
 
RP: 666
 
FFVI, Dragon Quest V, Chrono Trigger, Marathon trilogy, NetHack
Weakling, Deathspell Omega, Moonsorrow, Drudkh, GY!BE, etc.
Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Dr. Strangelove, Spinal Tap
A People's History of the U.S., Letter to a Christian Nation
SNES
     
 
Default  05.18.06, 21:39:26
  Post #4 (permalink)
 
     

Jack Thompson is the reason people insult Americans. End of story.

Basically, what Parks said.
Send a message via AIM to The Man Send a message via MSN to The Man   The Man is offline
View The Mans Profile! Find more posts by The Man!   Reply With Quote
  Darklai
 
 
Darklai's Avatar
Evening's Siren
 
Posts: 446
 
Reg: Apr 26 2003
 
ID: 5990
 
RP: 939
 
Final Fantasy VIII
Within Temptation
PS2 - SNES \m/
     
 
Default  05.18.06, 21:50:25
  Post #5 (permalink)
 
     

Like mentioned before, I think that blaming violence of games is just an excuse, a mere way to avoid the truth about being a bad parent. Irresponsible people nowadays.
______________________________________

~~~~~~~~ Forever One Of The Lost Ones ~~~~~~~~

Send a message via AIM to Darklai Send a message via MSN to Darklai Send a message via Yahoo to Darklai   Darklai is offline
View Darklais Profile! Find more posts by Darklai! Visit Darklais Homepage!   Reply With Quote
  Flyguy
 
 
Flyguy's Avatar
Registered User
 
Posts: 113
 
Reg: May 09 2002
 
ID: 780
 
RP: 0
 
Final Fantasy VII
Linkin Park
The Shawshank Redemption
Can't choose just one
SNES
     
 
Default  05.18.06, 22:34:44
  Post #6 (permalink)
 
     

I'm about to graduate from college with a bachelor's in psychology, so I know a little bit about how people think. It's my opinion that videogames don't cause violence, though they probably play a minor role in pushing some people over the edge. Humans have some level of inherited violent nature. If we didn't, our ancestors would have never survived in the wild 100,000 years ago. Since we are (somewhat) civilized today and violence is not neccissarily a part of everyday life, we use media like television and videogames as an outlet.

There are probably several reasons why things like school shootings occur. One is that kids grow up in violent neighborhoods where violence is a part of everyday life. They are then drawn to violent music, television, movies and videogames, which all further reinforce that being violent get's you what you want. The other major factor is when kids can't differentiate between fantasy and reality. Mental illnesses like depression are more common than people want to believe, and when kids have things like depression fantasy is much nicer than reality. We all know that when we blow a hole in someone with a shot gun in a videogame that it's fake and doing it in real life would be completely different. Kids with mental illnesses can forget that. They live in their fantasy world, which may be a videogame or a TV show or a movie.

The issue is a ton more complicated and I don't want to write a book, so that's what I think.
Send a message via AIM to Flyguy   Flyguy is offline
View Flyguys Profile! Find more posts by Flyguy!   Reply With Quote
  Kirk
 
 
Kirk's Avatar
James T
 
Posts: 7
 
Reg: May 21 2006
 
ID: 7400
 
RP: 0
 
age of empires
tenacious d
ice age or monsters inc
shining ones - david eddings
None
     
 
Default  05.23.06, 18:15:41
  Post #7 (permalink)
 
     

they thing is that rhe whole situation is just one massive circle. There are too many perverts and sick people outisde to let the kids out - the kids stay inside with nothing to do but play on the games that mummy and daddy got becasue it's a way of shutting them up. They grow up and have had it fed inot them that the outside world is sick - they get isolation madness (as happened in the columbine masacre and at least one other - the name escapes me) so then more people keeep their kids in coz of all the perverts and sickos. and round and round we go.
______________________________________


It's Life, Jim......but not as we know it!
Send a message via MSN to Kirk   Kirk is offline
View Kirks Profile! Find more posts by Kirk!   Reply With Quote
  Kionae
 
 
Kionae's Avatar
Pet teh kitteh...
 
Posts: 3,819
 
Reg: May 09 2006
 
ID: 7335
 
RP: 1499
 
Final Fantasy VII
Weird Al
The Princess Bride
Jurassic Park
PS2
     
 
Default  05.23.06, 18:43:17
  Post #8 (permalink)
 
     

It's already been said, but I think violence in youth is partly due to poor parently, and partly due to environment. If you're in a situation where you're essentially being raised by Grand Theft Auto 3, then, yeah... you're going to have a rather skewed view of reality. Likewise, if you're in a situation where you're surrounded by violence in real life, you're going to be more drawn to things like violent games.

Kids who go out and shoot people have more serious issues than their gaming habits.

Quote:
Quoth The Man:
Jack Thompson is the reason people insult Americans. End of story.
All I have to say to that is:
http://www.jinx.com/scripts/details....&productID=624

______________________________________


Lover of all things Turk... deranged, yaoi-obsessed fangirl of Reno...
Searching for my mind... I lost it somewhere...
Quote:
Quoth Kanis:
for the love of christ and all that is holy my anus is bleeding
Send a message via MSN to Kionae   Kionae is offline
View Kionaes Profile! Find more posts by Kionae! Visit Kionaes Homepage!   Reply With Quote
  Sar
 
 
Sar's Avatar
Heterosexual White Man
 
Posts: 2,467
 
Reg: Dec 23 2002
 
ID: 6128
 
RP: 1338
 
Tetris
Man Man / The Kinks / Of Montreal
No Country for Old Men / Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia
Blood Meridian or: The Evening Redness in the West
Super Nintendo
     
 
Default  05.23.06, 20:08:37
  Post #9 (permalink)
 
     

My dad said that violent video games don't create violent people, but violent people are attracted to violent video games, movies etc., and I whole-heartedly agree.

The effects that the games themselves have is that they probobly lessen your sense of empathy. If you run around and shoot people all day, it's going to blur the lines of reality somewhere in the chasms of your psyche, even if you can consciously differentiate between the two.

It's not just one thing that makes a kid blow his stack and shoot up a school, and video games are a common scapegoat.
Send a message via AIM to Sar Send a message via MSN to Sar   Sar is offline
View Sars Profile! Find more posts by Sar!